The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography


Which phone takes the best photos in 2019?

That is the million dollar question and to answer it, we are running a series of camera comparisons, starting with the blind tests, then focusing on features like the often-used Portrait Mode, then selfies, and now, it’s time for arguably the most important test: we have shot photos with the main cameras on the 6 most popular flagship phones of 2019.

In our hands, we have the following (in alphabetical order):

All of them are great devices, but which one has the best camera?

It’s time to find out in our completely open and honest test, where you will see 10 different scenes captured with these phones. We have gathered a small panel of photography enthusiasts as the jury and the photos were ranked blindly, without the jury knowing which phone took which photo. You can find our impressions from each phone in the conclusion at the bottom of the article, but right now, let’s jump right in and take a look at the photos.

Scene 1

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography
Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 8
Google Pixel 3 7.5
Huawei P30 Pro 5.5
LG G8 6.5
OnePlus 6T 6.5
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 6

Scene 2

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 7.5
Google Pixel 3 6
Huawei P30 Pro 6
LG G8 7
OnePlus 6T 8
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 5

Scene 3

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 8
Google Pixel 3 7.5
Huawei P30 Pro 4
LG G8 5
OnePlus 6T 5.5
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 4.8

Scene 4

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 6.5
Google Pixel 3 7.5
Huawei P30 Pro 4
LG G8 6
OnePlus 6T 5.5
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 8.5

Scene 5

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 7
Google Pixel 3 6
Huawei P30 Pro 4.5
LG G8 8
OnePlus 6T 6.5
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 7.5

Scene 6

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 7
Google Pixel 3 7.5
Huawei P30 Pro 6
LG G8 6.5
OnePlus 6T 5
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 6

Scene 7

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 6
Google Pixel 3 5
Huawei P30 Pro 4
LG G8 2.5
OnePlus 6T 5.5
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 8

Scene 8

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 9
Google Pixel 3 7
Huawei P30 Pro 5.5
LG G8 6
OnePlus 6T 4
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 7.5

Scene 9

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 8
Google Pixel 3 7
Huawei P30 Pro 4
LG G8 6
OnePlus 6T 3
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 5.5

Scene 10

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

Phone Score
Apple iPhone XS 7.5
Google Pixel 3 6
Huawei P30 Pro 4.5
LG G8 6.5
OnePlus 6T 7.5
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 4

Conclusion & Scores

The ULTIMATE 2019 Camera Comparison: Daytime Photography

With 10 different scenes openly presented to you and with quite a bit more that we looked through as we evaluated these phones, it’s time to draw some conclusions.

First of all, we should say that judging photos is no easy task: you can look at colors, dynamic range, details, exposure, noise, ease of use and so many other things. You can look at 100% crops at the center of an image, around the sides, you can look for lens vignetting, purple fringing and so on. While we did most of that, we feel that presenting all of that information piece by piece would be overwhelming and do more to confuse rather than help you understand which phone takes the best photos.

So that’s why we have settled on giving one overall score based on an estimation by a panel of judges here at PhoneArena. The phones were judged blindly to avoid any possible bias and the images were judged on a professionally calibrated monitor. With all of this in mind, here is a short summary of our impressions from each one of the phones.

Phone TOTAL
SCORE
Apple iPhone XS 7.45
Google Pixel 3 6.7
Samsung Galaxy S10+ 6.28
LG G8 6
OnePlus 6T 5.7
Huawei P30 Pro 4.8

Apple iPhone XS

Total score: 74.5, average of 7.45

The iPhone XS consistently captured balanced images with pleasing colors and it had plentiful detail without artificially over-sharpening the photo. Using the iPhone camera also felt reliable, safe and fast, with no surprising processing that would alter the appearance of the photo after you press the shutter button. The new Smart HDR option brings a welcome improvement to the dynamic range, so now you get more colors all across the range. Images were well exposed, white balance was spot-on and we also found that colors looked very close to reality, while other phones would often alter the tones more noticeably.

Google Pixel 3

Total score: 67, average of 6.7
The Pixel 3 captures a wide range of colors that mostly look good and its HDR+ option (enabled by default) impressed us. However, we found that it also consistently underexposes photos, so they look a bit darker than they should. It also tends to capture noticeably oversaturated colors which often looks good, but if you want to get a “natural” look, there is no easy way to get that on a Pixel.

Samsung Galaxy S10+

Total score: 62.8, average of 6.28

The Samsung Galaxy S10+ ranks very close to the iPhone and the Pixel in terms of photo quality during the day. Often times, it was able to strike the most pleasing balance of colors: vibrant greens, blue skies, great dynamic range, and in those cases it’s easily a winner. However, sometimes, photos out of it look artificially HDR-y or overprocessed, and those few imbalances make it a bit less predictable of a camera. We also noticed that in a few instances photos from the S10+ came out significantly overexposed, so they looked way too bright.

LG G8

Total score: 60, average of 6.0

The LG G8 did not do such a great job as the top three phones in this ranking, but it was not too far behind. Given the right conditions, it can capture some great-looking shots, but not consistently. Other times, photos would turn out underexposed or the colors would look dull and/or washed out for no apparent reason. Every phone comes with its specific colors and the thing that makes the LG images stand out is the slight greenish tint that you can spot on nearly all of its photos.

OnePlus 6T

Total score: 57, average of 5.7

The OnePlus 6T did a decent job, but it clearly does not yet belong in the elite club of the best smartphone cameras. It had a few good shots, but most of the time, photos from the OnePlus 6T had very dull colors, lacked contrast and had a very noticeable purple tint, and they just… did not stand out.

Huawei P30 Pro

Total score: 48, average of 4.8
The Huawei P30 Pro impressed us with its periscope camera and the ability to zoom in to crazy distances, but in this test that solely focused on the main camera it felt way behind the pack. This is not exactly a surprise as our blind camera comparison ranked it significantly behind the Galaxy S10+ and iPhone XS, but here again, you can see that the new RYYB sensor used in the phone just doesn’t capture good-looking colors. That’s the big issue: the P30 Pro was practically incapable of capturing the blue color in the skies and while it had plentiful detail, images from it appear less lively than from other phones, with a very noticeable yellow tint.





Source link

Share this article
onpost_follow

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.